Skip to main content

More than a Human vs Animal Issue

I had the opportunity to speak with my son’s English teacher about his concerns. It was a cordial and pleasant conversation. In fairness to her, I do not think she was trying to intentionally promote a radical PETA style agenda when she called into question my son’s view. Her intent in asking for the support of other students was more to stimulate discussion than to show by majority rules that his position was in error.

I also don’t think she realized how much she put her stamp of approval on the position that animal and human life are of equal value. She was trying to show the evolution of the main character from a position of total disregard for animal life to a position of valuing animal life. She presented two positions: human life is more valuable than animal life or human life is equal to animal life. The first position is the bad position of the main character in the beginning of the book and the second is the good position he learned as the story progresses. From our discussion, I gleaned that she did not want to delve into the more nuanced position that animal life can be respected but that does not make it of equal value to human life. She said the class is too chatty and easily distracted so she wanted to keep things focused and productive. It was really a matter of classroom expediency to offer just two choices of thought. She wanted the students to concentrate on the story and not bring in all these religious or philosophical viewpoints.

I fully expected to be writing a follow-up post to my son’s English class experience. However, I expected it to be an expository piece on the Catholic teaching about the relationship between man and animals. While that is an interesting topic, I think there are other points worthy of contemplation. First of all, I think there is something intrinsically flawed with a curriculum that must reduce everything to black and white and doesn’t have time for a sophisticated discussion of the gray. I am not blaming any one teacher for this. This is a systemic problem with our educational system. Specifically, the teaching of English has gone from teaching the skills of English communication and the appreciation of the artistry of the written word to indoctrination into approved ideas. My daughter experienced this last year with her AP literature class. The current trend in English class is to appreciate the political message of the literature. But great literature is not about politics. Literature becomes timeless when it touches the core themes of our humanity: love, loss, fear, good and evil. We can provide context to the writing of Shakespeare, Charles Dickens, and Jane Austen by knowing something of the politics and culture of their times. But their politics is not the point of their writing. The staying power of their writing is that it speaks to some element of the universal human experience. The focus on a contemporary message makes Oprah book club choices more useful than Jane Austen or Louisa May Alcott. It teaches the essence of propaganda, not literature.

Secondly, isn’t it sad that a teacher is surprised when a student brings his religious principles into the classroom? She fully expects students to compartmentalize their values and stow them away for English class. Of course, in a society that sees no contradiction when someone says, “I am personally opposed, but…” it is not surprising that students are expected to be able to expound a view totally at odds with their faith for the sake of the English class curriculum.

The problem is we are not compartmentalized beings. We are integrated body and spirit. We are called to let our faith permeate and influence every nook and cranny of our lives. This may put us out of sync with current trends in education, but it keeps us in sync with God.


Barb, sfo said…
It's very true that teachers and students have to "compartmentalize their religious beliefs and stow them away for English class." Having taught English on levels from elementary through college, at both public and Catholic schools, I have seen the difference. Personally I have a difficult time interpreting literature without looking through the lens of my faith, and considering the faith of the author. It does no one any justice when you have to set that aside in some attempt to be politically correct.
Elise B. said…
Another troubling fact in the story is that the teacher told your son that he must be wrong since no one supported him. This is a denial of any objective truth, regardless of how many people accept it.
There are exemples in modern history where the right view was upheld by a minority, at least officially: i.e. in Germany during WWII and in the Soviet Union.
J.C. said…
May I ask your reasons for not homeschooling? Your children sound bright and motivated. (I am entirely new to your blog, so please forgive me if you've already discussed this topic in previous posts...)
Catholic Mom said…

Welcome to the site! In response to your question, I will first refer you to this post. When I first started this parenting journey, I was still buying into the theory that you can do it all--high powered career, be a great mom, sew homemade Halloween costumes,etc. Once they started school I started cutting back on my work hours and eventually gave up clinical practice all together. I've kept my hand in some family friendly professional activities. Three of my four children are now out of high school so back in the day, home schooling is not near as common as it is now. I considered it with my youngest but wasn't brave enough to take the plunge. If I were starting out with school age children now, I would definitely consider home schooling. There is so much more support for this now than there was 15+ years ago.

Popular posts from this blog

Parent Letter from a Catechist

I am going to be teaching seventh grade CCD this year. We do most of the preparation for confirmation during this year since Confirmation is usually scheduled for the fall of the eighth grade year.I have composed a letter to the parents to try and keep them active in their children's religious education. I thought I would post it here and get your feedback before I send it out in a couple of weeks.

I am privileged to be your child’s seventh grade CCD teacher for the 2006-2007 school year. This is a very important year. We will focus on your child’s preparation for confirmation. Of course, you have already been preparing your child for this sacrament for many years. You are the primary catechist for your child. You show how important your Faith is by making Mass attendance a top priority and by family prayer.

Confirmation is one of the Sacraments of Initiation. It is a beginning. It is not a graduation. This year we will work to solidify the foundation of your child’s Catholic Faith.…

United Breaks Guitars

This guy is really talented and what a creative way to get your message across. I think he captured the "indifferent employee" perfectly. They don't just work for airlines. I think I ran into them at Walmart on Friday!

Dispelling the Myth of the Travel Dispensation

One of the fun things about having a site meter on my blog is I can see which posts garner the most attention. I can also see how people find my blog. One of the most read posts from my two years of blogging is this one that discusses finding Mass while traveling. I would like to think this post is so popular because it is so well written. The truth of the matter is that it generates so much traffic because I use the words “travel dispensation for Mass”—as in “There is no such thing as a travel dispensation for Mass.” I would guess that nearly a dozen times every week, someone googles “travel dispensation for Mass” and finds my blog. I wonder how many of these folks are poor souls trying to assuage their Catholic guilt with evidence of a justification for missing Mass while on the road.

I know that when I tell my seventh grade CCD students that attending Mass every Sunday is a commandment (one of the top ten!) and not just a pretty good idea they are amazed. Missing Mass has become so …